Today’s problem is Problem 6 on the UCLA Fall 2024 Analysis Qual:
Problem 6: Let be a measurable set such that
for all positive integers
Show that
or
where
is the Lebesgue measure.
Solution: Since the problem requires us to prove a statement with an exception of a measure zero set, we are likely to use measure theoretic machinery. In particular, notice that the above property of in fact implies that
i.e.
is
-invariant. The main tool in this problem turns out to be the Lebesgue differentiation theorem, which says that almost every point of a locally integrable function is a Lebesgue point, i.e. the average value of the function around the point converges to its value at that point.
Now, consider the function Pick
to be a Lebesgue point of
and note that
where
Either way, for any other Lebesgue point
and family of open balls
centered at
one has
as
where
are chosen so that
and
shrinks nicely to
as
By the Lebesgue differentiation theorem, we conclude that
at every Lebesgue point, that is, a.e. If
this implies
and otherwise
and we are done.
Remark: Note that this also implies that the set of Lebesgue points of is precisely